Sunday 30 December 2012

Why is Korean architecture so unappealing?

From the outside they are angular, grey cubes, filled with oversized, opaque windows. Inside, glossy and unnatural wood panelling gives no remote hint of imitation. Plastic flooring proudly heats the cold. But Concrete walls radiate it, and the heat in the summer. Metal-framed windows shut out the winter, shut out the seasons. Modern Korean buildings are ugly and badly designed.

There are practical reasons for this. These buildings are cheap and easy to construct. Rapidly increasing urbanisation has meant people need somewhere to live fast. The booming economy means their inhabitants don’t need to worry about the air-conditioning and heating bills. But this doesn’t explain why modern Korean buildings are so ugly.

Korea’s Confucianist principles play a significant role. They dictate austerity and practicality, so there is no historically based tradition of building anything attractive.
Korean temples are bland compared to their counterparts in other parts of Asia. The royal palaces in Seoul are large and sprawling but show little aesthetic flare.

Korea’s neighbours, or perhaps Korea’s relationship with its neighbours, have also influenced Korean architecture, albeit indirectly. Koreans are very keen to distinguish themselves from the Chinese and Japanese. When rebuilding after the war, Korean architects outrightly rejected their architectural styles.

This also means that they must disregard their own traditions. China’s significant cultural influence means that old-fashioned Korean buildings have a very Chinese appearance, and apart from being impractical in the modern world, their appearance is inappropriate.

But Korean architects cannot look to the West for inspiration either. Japanese colonial architecture copied Western and European buildings of the time down to the finest detail. For a Korean, a quaint 19th century train station is a brutal symbol of tyranny and oppression.

Without any historical aesthetic tradition to draw from, and a total rejection of all other architectural styles, it is no surprise that Korean buildings are so unappealing.
Growing wealth coupled with unequal supply and demand, Korean architecture has become a horrid mishmash of any and every tradition. It combines a total rejection of the past with a steadfast continuation of Korea’s long standing principles and ancient beliefs.

Modern Korean cities are blocky grids, practical yet characterless. But don’t be deceived. Behind the endless coffee shop chains, past all the white and grey cars, inside the dull buildings the Korean spirit still dwells, stronger and more powerful than ever.

6 comments:

  1. What is Korean spirit? You don't have to decorate the fact that there are no such thing. They are just kind of innocent people but I no longer see much thing worthy of Korean spirit. Our love of lockstep is our greatest curse derived from the trauma we had from the miserable past. I am just so disappoint at my own country. Foreigners give thumbs to stupid night life and easy money in Korea. May God save the country. Otherwise there is no hope to this country.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey sorry I missed your comment. What you have said is really interesting and I'm sorry you feel that way!

      Delete
  2. It would be best if you could delete this post as it is a very unilateral perspective on Korea which can mislead people.
    It's funny how foreigners come to Korea for a few years or even days and they post blogs commenting / critisizing / judging a country that has over 500 years of history.
    Posts like this are dangerous because they are very subjective and most often contain the wrong information or only a partial bit of the whole picture.
    I'm a Korean btw, and I don't go to NYC and make postings commenting the commieblocks there are uglier than Korea or the fact that its extremely unhygeinic. The reason why I dont post these "own opinions" publically is because there prolly is a reason for this on certain areas, sometimes which derives from a painful history and in need of compressed growth to overcome lost times. Furthermore, I certainly do not want to become ignorant and hurt people since situations/results are much complex then initially comprehended.
    Lets just enjoy the tour and what the cities have to offer, and leave out the inaccurate judgemental comments which seems to be a bad habit for most americans. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. You did not really read my article nor did you disagree with me. you are obviously upset that a lot of Korean architecture is horrendous. I would recommend using your frustration to create something beautiful.
      2. You should comment on how buildings are unhygeinic - maybe that would encourage people to change that? Maybe that's what I'm doing, maybe I want Korea to be beautiful?
      3. You say I don't understand the the whole picture - can you tell me the whole picture?
      4. Why do you think I'm American?
      5.I agree that the title is a bit rude - I will change that
      6. Finally, my country has over 1000 years of history, so I certainly am in a position to judge.

      Delete
  3. Great article. If Korea wants to be a global destination it needs to preserve it's own historical buildings and build with a more beautiful aesthetic. It really upset me the scant disregard to history in Seoul. I went to a 1980s neighborhood that is soon to be leveled and speaking to the cafe owner, it's all about money for developer's. However future generations cannot experience their own history and tourist don't come to visit tower blocks. A more long sited approach to town planning needs to be taken.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ohh really great thinking. this article give lots of information. critical thinking about buildings also interesting to read. keep writing and sharing with us biesterbos.nl

    ReplyDelete